The Macallan 1824 is a series of whiskies aimed at the travel retail section (duty free shops), and consists of four expressions : Select Oak, Whisky Maker’s Edition, Estate Reserve and 1824 Limited Release. Those whiskies do not carry an age statement and are supposed to be crafted by the now retired John Ramsey (who was the Master whisky maker of the Edrington group, the owner of The Macallan).
The Select Oak is a vatting of a few types of cask hand picked by the Master of Wood at The Macallan, George Espie. This Expression was matured in three cask types – American Oak seasoned with either Sherry or Bourbon (which contribute to butterscotch and vanilla flavors) and first-fill European oak casks seasoned with Sherry which contribute sweet spice flavors. This combination of casks should give the whisky smoothness, and complexity.
Well, let’s put this to the test. shall we?
The Macallan Select Oak , 40% ABV , NAS
Color : Pale Gold.
Nose: Fruity, sweet, sherry notes, new leather and spice. This is not a fully sherried profile, but the essentials are there. Sweet, and vibrant, yet not heavy, if you get what i mean. very appetizing.
Palate : Sherry, spices, oak, quite fruity. ending on a wee cocoa and milk chocolate . Some nuts too. Clearly the first fill sherry oak is playing first violin here.
Finish : dried fruit salad, chocolate. spicy on the finish, pepper, nutmeg.
Summing it all Up:
The Select Oak is a fine dram, while it’s evident the sherry casks are quite dominant here, it does not match the 100 % sherried Macallans I do love so much, yet it offers some very nice combination of sherry and Bourbon notes, which are quite nicely integrated. A great after dinner dram. Again, 40% close but no cigar. I would love to see a 48% version of this malt, and no doubt it would be ten times better with the higher ABV.
Slainte!
You know, I passed this one up last time I was in a Duty Free shop. This was before my rediscovery of The Macallan. Next time I’m in a duty-free, I may just pick this baby up. Though, like you, I think 40%ABV is just not enough — for any whisky really. Then again, the Crag12 is only 40% and that one is a cracker for sure!
Yea. but i think if u are in a duty free shop, better get some vintage HP… 😉
Crag is a cracker, just think of how good it will be at 50%…
anyways, let’s decree a law, forcing distilleries to bottle at CS only….
are you with me?
Oh, if I had it my way, all drams would be Cask Strength. Let’s give the consumer the ability to water down if he or she likes.
Then again, from a distiller’s standpoint, some (maybe most) people have a tough time with whiskies beyond 40-43%. I think they’re afraid of scaring away consumers. There should be side by side bottlings for all OB’s! If you want a 43% HP12, you got it! Oh, you prefer a CS version?? Here you go!
great idea.
one for those who buy whiskies as a present and one for connosrs 😉
Also, last time i was in a DFS, it was right before the new HP vintages were released! I missed it by two weeks!
You know, I passed this one up last time I was in a Duty Free shop. This was before my rediscovery of The Macallan. Next time I'm in a duty-free, I may just pick this baby up. Though, like you, I think 40%ABV is just not enough — for any whisky really. Then again, the Crag12 is only 40% and that one is a cracker for sure!
Yea. but i think if u are in a duty free shop, better get some vintage HP… 😉
Crag is a cracker, just think of how good it will be at 50%…
anyways, let's decree a law, forcing distilleries to bottle at CS only….
are you with me?
Oh, if I had it my way, all drams would be Cask Strength. Let's give the consumer the ability to water down if he or she likes.
Then again, from a distiller's standpoint, some (maybe most) people have a tough time with whiskies beyond 40-43%. I think they're afraid of scaring away consumers. There should be side by side bottlings for all OB's! If you want a 43% HP12, you got it! Oh, you prefer a CS version?? Here you go!
Also, last time i was in a DFS, it was right before the new HP vintages were released! I missed it by two weeks!
great idea.
one for those who buy whiskies as a present and one for connosrs 😉